Appealing Private Insurance Denials

Attorney Rich Newsome

Legally Reviewed By

Attorney Rich Newsome

Catastrophic Injury & Medical Malpractice Attorney

25+ years experience

Read About Attorney Rich Newsome

Appealing Private Insurance Denials

Locked-in syndrome requires expensive, long-term care, and insurance denials are common. These denials are frustrating and scary, but you have the right to appeal.

You Can Challenge an Insurance Denial

A denial letter often arrives at the hardest possible moment. Your loved one may still be in the hospital or a rehabilitation unit. You are learning a new way to communicate with them while managing calls, forms, and decisions. Reading that a device, a nursing service, or a course of therapy will not be covered can feel final.

It is a decision that can be reviewed. Most private health plans give members the right to ask the insurer to reconsider, and many also allow a review by an independent party outside the company.

Few families use these rights. In federal data on 2024 Marketplace plans, fewer than one percent of denied claims were appealed. When people did appeal, insurers kept their original decision about two-thirds of the time, per KFF. Roughly one in three appeals ended with the denial reversed at that first stage. The same data show that only about five percent of denials rested on medical necessity, while nine percent came from a missing prior authorization or referral. These are problems that better paperwork can often solve.

People with locked-in syndrome have a strong foundation for an appeal. Your loved one is aware, thinking, and feeling, but entirely paralyzed. The care they need protects their ability to breathe safely, avoid complications, and express their own wishes. An appeal that shows this clearly gives reviewers a full picture of the person behind the claim.

Why Insurers Deny Locked-In Syndrome Care

Insurers review each claim against the plan’s terms and their own clinical guidelines. Locked-in syndrome is rare and complex, and those guidelines may not fit your loved one’s needs well. Knowing the reason for a denial tells you what the appeal must show.

  • Medical necessity. The insurer has decided the record does not support the requirement for the service. This often reflects a documentation gap, which detailed letters from the treating team can fill.
  • Missing prior authorization or referral. A required approval was not on file before care began. Submitting the request now can often correct these denials.
  • Custodial rather than skilled care. Insurers may classify nursing care as helping with daily activities. Airway management, tube feeding, and speech or physical therapy require licensed clinical judgment, and the record should say so.
  • No further progress expected. Therapy may be cut when gains slow. Many people with locked-in syndrome need ongoing therapy to keep the movement and strength they have and to prevent decline.
  • Excluded or convenience items. Some plans treat eye-gaze systems or adapted tablets as general electronics. For a person who cannot speak, these devices are how they report pain, make choices, and give consent.
  • Network or level of care. The insurer may say a provider is out of network. It may also say a lower level of care is enough, such as a skilled nursing facility instead of inpatient rehabilitation.

Your denial letter should name the reason. If it is unclear, call the insurer and ask for the reason in writing.

Before You Write Anything, Gather the Full Record

A strong appeal begins with knowing exactly what the insurer relied on. Before drafting an appeal letter, collect the documents that shaped the decision and the ones that can change it.

  • Start with the denial letter itself. Note the reason given, the appeal instructions, and the deadline printed on the letter.
  • Request the complete claim file and the specific clinical criteria or guideline the insurer used. Insurers generally provide these on request, and they show you what the reviewer expects to see.
  • Ask for the full plan document as well. The short benefits summary often leaves out exclusions and exceptions that can shape your appeal.
  • Gather physician notes, therapy evaluations, nursing assessments, and the current care plan from the care team. Ask the treating physician whether they are willing to write a letter of medical necessity or speak with the insurer directly.

Keep a simple log of every call, with the date, the person you spoke with, and any reference number. Store copies of everything you send and receive. If you mail anything, keep proof of delivery.

Appealing Skilled Nursing Denials

Skilled nursing denials often rest on one question: does your loved one’s care require a licensed nurse’s clinical judgment, or only help with daily activities? Your appeal should answer that question with specifics.

Ask the care team to document each skilled need in detail. For many people with locked-in syndrome, this includes:

  • Airway and ventilator management
  • Suctioning
  • Tube feeding
  • Monitoring for aspiration
  • Repositioning and skin checks to prevent pressure injuries

The record should describe how often these tasks happen and what clinical decisions they involve.

Be prepared for the word “stable.” Insurers sometimes read stability as a sign that skilled care can end. Ask the treating physician to explain that your loved one’s stability depends on the skilled care they receive. The physician should also describe the risks if that care stopped, such as pneumonia, infection, or serious skin breakdown.

If the insurer approved a lower level of care, ask the physician to explain why that setting cannot safely meet your loved one’s needs.

Were You a Victim of Medical Negligence?

If a delayed diagnosis led to permanent harm, you may be entitled to compensation. Speak with our legal team today.

Start My Free Case Review arrow blacks

Appealing Rehabilitation Therapy Denials

Therapy denials often follow a progress report showing that gains have slowed. For a person with locked-in syndrome, slower progress can still mean important work, and the appeal should show what that work protects.

Ask each therapist to document specific, measurable goals.

If the insurer says no further progress is expected, request the plan’s criteria for therapy coverage. Some plans cover therapy that maintains function or prevents decline. Ask the treating physician to describe what would likely happen without continued therapy, such as stiffening joints, pain, or loss of the movement that remains.

When the dispute is about level of care, such as inpatient rehabilitation versus a skilled nursing facility, the physician can explain why your loved one needs the intensity of one setting over the other.

If the plan limits the number of visits, ask whether it allows exceptions, and submit the therapists’ documentation with your request.

Appealing a Denied Eye-Gaze or AAC Device

For many people with locked-in syndrome, an eye-gaze device is the only way to communicate in full sentences. A strong appeal shows that the device meets a medical need.

The foundation is an evaluation by a speech-language pathologist. It should describe:

  • Your loved one’s eye control and endurance
  • The communication methods already tried
  • Why low-tech boards alone cannot meet their needs

The treating physician’s prescription and letter of medical necessity should connect the device to the diagnosis and to specific goals.

Explain what is at stake without the device. A person who cannot communicate cannot report pain, breathing trouble, or a problem with their care, and cannot take part in their own medical decisions.

If your loved one used a device during a trial, consider including a short statement they composed, with their consent. Their own words show reviewers the person the device serves.

Finally, ask the plan how the care setting affects coverage. Some plans treat devices differently when a person lives in a nursing facility, so raise this before discharge decisions are final.

What to Expect from the Appeals Process

Most appeals begin with an internal appeal, a written request asking the insurer to reconsider. The treating physician may also request a peer-to-peer review with the insurer’s clinician, which can resolve some denials quickly. If waiting could seriously harm your loved one’s health, ask for an expedited review. If the denial stands, you can often request an external review by an independent reviewer. Your state insurance department can explain which options apply to you.

While you wait, your state’s assistive technology program may loan an eye-gaze device, and alphabet boards keep your loved one’s voice in the conversation. A hospital social worker or case manager can help you find other short-term support.

Read more about Rich Newsome linkedin
Rich Newsome

Rich Newsome

Catastrophic Injury Locked-In Syndrome Attorney

Rich Newsome is a dedicated attorney specializing in catastrophic injury and medical malpractice cases. With over 25 years of experience, she is committed to advocating for victims and their families, ensuring they receive the justice and compensation they deserve.

Let's Connect

Navigation